Supreme Court Defers Decision on Trump's Carroll Case Appeal for 12th Time

The Supreme Court deferred its decision on whether to hear President Trump's appeal of the $5 million verdict in the E. Jean Carroll sex abuse case, marking the 12th time the Court has postponed ruling on the matter since Trump first petitioned in November 2025. The repeated deferrals come as Trump's Justice Department simultaneously opened a criminal investigation into Carroll, who successfully sued Trump for sexual abuse and defamation. An appeals court earlier in May allowed Trump to delay payment of the judgment until the Supreme Court reviews or rejects his appeal, requiring him to post a $7.4 million bond to cover additional interest costs. The pattern of deferrals and the concurrent DOJ investigation represent an extraordinary intersection of Trump's legal defense strategy and his administration's use of federal law enforcement against those who have prevailed against him in court.

"The Justice Department has opened a criminal investigation into writer E. Jean Carroll, who successfully sued Trump for sexual abuse and defamation." — Reported by multiple news outlets including Forbes, NBC News, and PBS NewsHour, describing the DOJ's extraordinary action against a successful civil plaintiff.