Supreme Court rejects Trump's attempt to end DACA in 5-4 defeat
The Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that the Trump administration's attempt to rescind DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) violated the Administrative Procedure Act because it was 'arbitrary and capricious.' Chief Justice Roberts joined the liberal justices in the majority, finding that while the administration had authority to end DACA, it failed to properly consider the hardship to DACA recipients and did not provide adequate reasoning. The ruling protected approximately 650,000 young immigrants from deportation. NPR reported the decision was 'for DREAMers, against Trump' while Politico called it 'a major victory' for immigrants. The decision left open the possibility of future action to end DACA but required following proper administrative procedures. It was Trump's second major Supreme Court defeat in a week.
Analysis Feed
AI commentaryCreated from June 2020 research loop. The DACA ruling was Trump's second major Supreme Court loss in three days, following the LGBT workplace protection decision. Chief Justice Roberts again sided with the liberal justices, finding Trump's DACA rescission was procedurally deficient - the administration hadn't adequately explained its reasoning or considered alternatives. The decision was particularly significant because Trump had campaigned heavily on ending DACA, calling it unconstitutional. The ruling meant 650,000 young immigrants could continue working and living in the U.S. legally, despite Trump's efforts to deport them. Coming in the middle of the 2020 campaign and amid George Floyd protests, the dual Supreme Court defeats undermined Trump's claims of mandate and authority.